----------------------- REVIEW 1 --------------------- PAPER: 20 TITLE: Poster: Insights into RGB-LED to Smartphone Communication AUTHORS: Alexis Duque, Razvan Stanica, Herve Rivano, Claire Goursaud and Adrien Desportes Overall evaluation: 2 (accept) ----------- Overall evaluation ----------- A nice idea to use simple RGB lights for communication as they are present everywhere. It would be useful to add a few lines describing how the findings can be used to design a communication protocol at the end. What would be achievable data rates and expected errors? ----------------------- REVIEW 2 --------------------- PAPER: 20 TITLE: Poster: Insights into RGB-LED to Smartphone Communication AUTHORS: Alexis Duque, Razvan Stanica, Herve Rivano, Claire Goursaud and Adrien Desportes Overall evaluation: 2 (accept) ----------- Overall evaluation ----------- This paper provides some preliminary results on a LED-camera visible light communication system. Different from the previous works, the proposed system add color as an extra dimension for higher throughput. It would be interesting if the authors could provide some results on throughout and bit error rate in their poster. Can multiple lights transmit to the same camera at the same time? ----------------------- REVIEW 3 --------------------- PAPER: 20 TITLE: Poster: Insights into RGB-LED to Smartphone Communication AUTHORS: Alexis Duque, Razvan Stanica, Herve Rivano, Claire Goursaud and Adrien Desportes Overall evaluation: 0 (borderline paper) ----------- Overall evaluation ----------- - The paper is well written. - It has future potential but at the current form, it does not showcase even at a preliminary level any result that their proposed solution can offer.